← All articles
StrategyNovember 14, 2026·8 min read

Etsy Alternatives: Sites Like Etsy for Sellers

Sites like Etsy from a seller's view: eBay, Amazon Handmade and your own store (Shopify). Fees, who can sell, the buyers, and when each one makes sense.


Short answer: the most common Etsy alternatives for sellers are eBay, Amazon Handmade and your own store built on a platform like Shopify. eBay lets you sell almost anything, new or used; Amazon Handmade is open only to approved handmade makers; your own store gives you full control, but you have to bring the traffic. What sets Etsy apart is that buyers come there specifically for handmade, personalized and vintage items.

Etsy and its alternatives at a glance

Sources: Etsy Fees & Payments Policy, Etsy Payments Policy, eBay Selling fees, Amazon Handmade and Selling plans, Shopify Pricing
PlatformWho can sellBasic feesTraffic
EtsyItems you make or design, vintage (at least 20 years old) and craft supplies$0.20 per listing + 6.5% transaction + payment processing (3% + $0.25 in the US)Etsy search and Etsy ads
eBayAlmost anything legal, new or used250 free listings a month; 13.6% + $0.40 per order in most categorieseBay search; auctions available
Amazon HandmadeHandmade makers who apply and get approved15% or at least $0.30 per unit; no monthly plan fee after the first month for approved sellersAmazon search
Your own store (Shopify)Almost anything legalMonthly subscription (price varies by country) + payment provider feesTraffic you bring: SEO, social media, ads

eBay: a wide product range and auctions

On eBay you can sell used items, branded goods, parts and collectibles that Etsy doesn't accept. One final value fee is taken per sale, with no separate payment processing fee. Handmade items sell there too, but buyers looking for handmade and personalized items are more often on Etsy.

Amazon Handmade: for approved makers

For Amazon Handmade you register as a Professional seller, apply and get approved. Your products must be hand-altered, hand-designed, handcrafted, repurposed or upcycled. The $39.99 monthly Professional plan fee is waived for approved Handmade sellers after the first month; sales carry a referral fee of 15% or at least $0.30 per unit.

Your own store: full control, your own traffic

If you open your own store on a platform like Shopify, the design, domain and customer data are yours; instead of listing and transaction fees, you pay a monthly subscription and payment fees. But there are no built-in buyers: you bring visitors through search engines, social media and ads. That's why many sellers open their own site as a second channel after building sales on Etsy.

Check this before you leave Etsy

Sellers usually look for alternatives because of fees or a lack of sales. Before switching platforms, check two things:

  1. What are your real fees? Calculate them for your country and price, including sales from Offsite Ads. If you're under the $10,000 threshold, you can opt out of Offsite Ads.
  2. Why aren't you getting sales? If your listings don't show up in search, the problem may be your titles, tags and photos rather than the platform, and you'd have the same problem elsewhere.

Selling on more than one platform

  • Make sure your product meets each platform's rules (Etsy doesn't allow reselling mass-produced items).
  • If you have only one in stock, remove it from the other platforms as soon as it sells.
  • Calculate each platform's fees at your own price; the same price doesn't leave the same profit everywhere.
  • Build steady sales on one channel before adding a second.
💡

If you want to stay on Etsy and grow sales, use Listimize to find products with demand in your niche and the keywords buyers search, then check your listings with the SEO Score.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to Etsy?

It depends on your product. eBay for used items and a wide range, Amazon Handmade for approved handmade products, and your own store on a platform like Shopify for full control.

Is there a cheaper site than Etsy?

Each platform's fees work differently. On a $35 example sale, Etsy's fees come to $3.78, eBay's to $5.16 and Amazon Handmade's to $5.25; on Etsy sales from Offsite Ads, the gap can close.

Do you need approval to sell on Amazon Handmade?

Yes. Only handmade products are accepted, through an application and audit.

Can I use Etsy and my own website together?

Yes. Many sellers use Etsy's buyer traffic while growing their own site as a second channel.

Free toolEtsy Fee CalculatorBefore switching platforms, see Etsy's real fees for your country.

Put these tactics to work in your shop

See your SEO score, spot trends and calculate your profit with Listimize — start for free.

Create a free account