Short answer: on Etsy you don't need to apply and there's no monthly fee; you pay $0.20 per listing plus transaction and payment fees per sale. Amazon Handmade requires an application and approval; it needs a Professional selling plan, but approved sellers don't pay the monthly fee after the first month. It takes a referral fee of 15% or at least $0.30 per unit sold. On the $35 example sale Etsy takes less, but Amazon's shoppers are a different audience.
Etsy vs Amazon Handmade at a glance
| Etsy | Amazon Handmade | |
|---|---|---|
| Application | Not needed; you open your shop | Application and approval required |
| Monthly fee | None (Etsy Plus is optional) | Professional plan $39.99/month; waived after the first month for approved Handmade sellers |
| Listing fee | $0.20 per listing | None |
| Selling fee | 6.5% transaction + payment processing (3% + $0.25 in the US) | 15% or at least $0.30 per unit |
| What you can sell | Items you make or design, vintage and craft supplies | Handmade: hand-altered, hand-designed, handcrafted, repurposed, upcycled |
Fees: a worked example
A $30 item with $5 shipping, a $35 sale in total (tax excluded):
| Etsy (US bank account) | Amazon Handmade | |
|---|---|---|
| Listing fee | $0.20 | $0 |
| Selling fees | 6.5% = $2.28 + 3% + $0.25 = $1.30 | 15% = $5.25 |
| Total fees | $3.78 | $5.25 |
If the Etsy order comes from an Offsite Ads click, another 15% is added to the same sale, and the two platforms' fees get close. Use the calculator to check with your own price and country.
Who can sell on Amazon Handmade?
Only approved makers and collaborative groups like cooperatives and nonprofits can sell on Amazon Handmade. You first register as a Professional seller, confirm you'll follow the Handmade guidelines, and apply with information about yourself, your products and your process. Once approved, you add the Handmade classification to your products: hand-altered (like a printed T-shirt or mug), hand-designed (like an art print), handcrafted (like a hand-carved wooden bowl), repurposed or upcycled.
Shoppers and discovery
Shoppers on Etsy come looking for handmade, personalized and one-of-a-kind items, and you compete with sellers like you in search and on category pages. Amazon Handmade opens you to Amazon's general audience, and your product is found through Amazon search. On Etsy, discovery depends on your title, tags, category and photos; on Amazon, on your title and search terms.
Which one suits you?
- If you're just starting and don't want to wait for approval: Etsy.
- If you sell digital downloads or vintage: Etsy; its rules explicitly allow both.
- If you already sell on Amazon and your products are handmade: a Handmade application may make sense.
- If you use both, track a single stock across both; remove an item from one platform as soon as it sells on the other.
If you're starting on Etsy, use Listimize to find products with demand in your niche and the keywords buyers search, then check your first listings with the SEO Score.
Frequently asked questions
Does Amazon Handmade cost money?
The Professional plan is $39.99/month, but approved Handmade sellers don't pay the monthly fee after the first month. Sales carry a referral fee of 15% or at least $0.30 per unit.
Is Etsy or Amazon Handmade cheaper?
On the $35 example sale, Etsy's fees are $3.78 and Amazon Handmade's are $5.25. On Etsy sales from Offsite Ads, the gap can close.
Do you have to apply to Amazon Handmade?
Yes. Amazon uses an application and audit process so only genuine handmade products are sold.
Do you need approval to open an Etsy shop?
No. You complete identity and payment verification and open your shop.

