Short answer: on Etsy, buyers rate an order from 1 to 5 stars and can leave a review within 100 days of the delivery date (or estimated delivery date). Your shop score is an average where the last 12 months carry the most weight and each rating's weight halves every year. For a negative review, first look for a fix privately by message; if that fails, you can post one public response. Etsy only removes reviews that violate its policies.
When can a buyer leave a review?
- Buyers have 100 days to review, starting on the delivery date or estimated delivery date.
- With delivery tracking, the delivery date is when the carrier marks the order as Delivered.
- Without tracking, the estimated delivery date = purchase date + processing time + shipping days.
- For digital items, the 100 days begin when the buyer downloads the file.
- Reviews can only be left for items sold through Etsy.
How is your review score calculated?
Your score is a recency-weighted average of all the star ratings you've received. Reviews from the past 12 months carry the most weight; each rating keeps its star value, but its weight in the average halves every year. So the effect of an old bad review fades over time, and your recent service matters most.
Where to see your reviews
In Shop Manager, select your shop name under Sales Channels and click the star rating, or scroll to the Reviews section. In the Etsy Seller app, go to More > Shop > Reviews. You can download all your reviews as a JSON file under Settings > Options > Download data > Download Your Reviews.
What to do about a negative review
Try to fix it privately first
As long as you haven't responded, the buyer can edit their review within 100 days of the estimated delivery date. Find the order in Shop Manager > Orders and message the buyer with the mail icon. If you understand the problem, offer a fix; if not, ask polite, open questions. A quick, solution-focused reply may lead the buyer to edit the review.
Respond publicly if you need to
- You have 100 days from the date the buyer last edited the review to respond.
- You can respond only once per review; you can't edit the response, but you can delete it.
- Once you respond, the buyer can no longer change the review or rating (even if you delete your response).
- Don't include tracking numbers, external links or private information.
Remember you're writing for every future visitor, not just this buyer: keep it short, focus on the product and service rather than the reviewer, and say what the problem was and what you changed.
Which reviews does Etsy remove?
Etsy doesn't remove negative reviews that follow its policies, and it doesn't delete reviews at a seller's request. A review, or its photo or video, violates the policies and can be reported with Report this review if it:
- Contains private identifying information
- Contains obscene, racist or harassing language or imagery
- Violates the Anti-Discrimination Policy
- Contains prohibited medical claims
- Is only advertising or spam
- Is only about things outside the seller's control (a named shipping carrier, Etsy or a third party)
- Contains threats or extortion
- Falsely inflates a shop's review score
A review that covers the item as well as the carrier may not qualify for removal. Etsy doesn't judge whether a buyer's opinion about quality, materials, the description or communication is accurate.
How to get more good reviews
- Make your description and photos match the item exactly: size, color, materials, personalization. A gap between expectation and the item is a leading cause of bad reviews.
- Set a realistic processing time and ship with tracking; orders that meet the estimated delivery date bring fewer complaints.
- Reply to buyer messages quickly.
- Pack with care; a damaged item means both a review and a refund.
- Fix the issue raised in a bad review and say what you changed in your response.
Most bad reviews start with missing listing details. Listimize's SEO Score shows missing size, material and photo details in your listing, and AI Optimize helps you complete your description.
Frequently asked questions
How long do buyers have to leave an Etsy review?
100 days from the delivery date or estimated delivery date. For digital items, the clock starts when the file is downloaded.
Can a negative Etsy review be removed?
Only if it violates Etsy's policies. Negative reviews that follow the rules aren't removed at a seller's request.
Can a buyer change a review after I respond?
No. Once you respond, the buyer can't edit the review or rating, even if you delete your response.
How much does an old bad review affect my score?
Its weight halves every year; reviews from the last 12 months count the most.
Sources
- Etsy Help: How the Review System Works for Sellers
- Etsy Help: What to Do if You Receive a Negative Review
Checked on November 14, 2026

