← All articles
Shop ManagementNovember 16, 2026·6 min read

Etsy Case: What Sellers Should Do When a Buyer Opens One

When an Etsy buyer can open a case, the four case reasons, how Etsy decides, the $250 Purchase Protection limit and how to respond to a case as a seller in Shop Manager.


Short answer: a case is a buyer's formal report to Etsy about an unresolved problem with an order. Buyers can only open one for four reasons: the order didn't arrive, it isn't as described, it arrived damaged, or it arrived 7+ days after the estimated delivery window. Etsy decides most cases from shipping status and Purchase Protection rules; if the order is eligible, the buyer gets a full refund and Etsy covers up to $250 of it. Sellers follow the case in Shop Manager > Help > Cases.

When can a buyer open a case on Etsy?

  • The order's maximum estimated delivery date has passed.
  • At least 48 hours have passed since the buyer contacted you about the problem.
  • For a non-delivery case, 7+ days must pass after the maximum estimated delivery date.
  • Once eligible, the buyer has 30 days to open a case.
💡

The 48-hour rule is your chance to fix it. Answer the buyer within that time and offer a solution; most problems close before they become a case.

What happens after a case is opened?

Source: Etsy Help, How to Resolve a Case from a Buyer
SituationOutcome
Order is eligible for Purchase ProtectionBuyer gets a full refund; Etsy covers up to $250, the rest is charged to the seller; you don't issue it yourself
Etsy needs more informationYou're notified in the case log and by email; you must respond
Non-delivery caseEtsy needs proof it shipped to the address on the Etsy receipt or agreed in Messages; valid tracking is key
Not as described or damagedA case agent reviews and decides

Etsy can resolve a case on your behalf if needed, including refunding the buyer and taking the funds from your Payment account. Not every case counts against your shop as long as you meet the customer service standard.

How to respond to an Etsy case as a seller

  1. On Etsy.com, go to Shop Manager.
  2. Go to Help, then Cases.
  3. Open the Cases reported about your shop tab and select the case ID.
  4. Write in the Add Your Comment box; use Attach Image to upload screenshots or photos.
  5. Depending on the order, you may also be able to issue a refund or update shipping info.

Keep every piece of information about the case in the case log. For not-as-described or damaged cases, acknowledge the buyer's concern, be patient and focus on making it right. If you have questions about a ruling, ask the case agent in the case log.

How does a case get closed?

  • You issue a full refund through Etsy Payments.
  • For non-delivery cases, there's no tracking, or tracking shows delivery to the address on the Etsy receipt.
  • The buyer closes it because they're happy with the outcome.
  • If the buyer paid with their own PayPal account instead of Etsy Payments, you may need to show proof of a PayPal refund.

If you disagree with the outcome of a closed not-as-described or damaged case, you can contact Etsy.

How to get fewer cases

  • Add valid tracking to every order.
  • Set realistic processing and delivery times.
  • Describe the item exactly as it is; state size, color and materials clearly.
  • Pack items well to prevent damage.
💡

Not-as-described cases often start with missing listing details. Listimize's SEO Score shows what your description is missing; a listing that sets the right expectations lowers your case risk.

Frequently asked questions

What can a buyer open an Etsy case for?

If the order didn't arrive, isn't as described, arrived damaged, or arrived 7+ days after the estimated delivery window.

How long does a buyer have to wait to open a case?

The maximum estimated delivery date must pass and at least 48 hours must pass after contacting the seller. Non-delivery cases need 7+ days after that date. Once eligible, the buyer has 30 days.

Who pays the refund in an Etsy case?

If the order is eligible for Purchase Protection, Etsy covers up to $250 of the refund and the rest is charged to the seller.

Where do I respond to a case?

In Shop Manager > Help > Cases, open the case from the Cases reported about your shop tab and write in the Add Your Comment box.

Free toolEtsy SEO OptimizationListings that set the right expectations mean fewer cases.

Put these tactics to work in your shop

See your SEO score, spot trends and calculate your profit with Listimize — start for free.

Create a free account